I built my Up 40 % Free Stock Strategy on one promise:
Buy. Let it rise. Take back your money. Keep the rest forever.
It worked beautifully — until Tesla (TSLA).
For the first time, I broke my own rule and dumped a stock I once planned to keep for life.
The Emotional Side: Selling My Hero
I bought Tesla because it embodied everything I like: vision, technology, growth, and a dose of drama. It delivered 10× gains to early believers, electrified an entire industry, and made “Elon” a first-name brand.
But lately, holding Tesla started to feel like clinging to an old phone that no longer updates properly. The shine faded, and reality crept in.
So yes — I sold. And I didn’t even wait for a trailing stop.
Why I Dumped Tesla (TSLA)
1. The Cars Just Don’t Improve Fast Enough
For a company supposedly “years ahead,” Tesla’s lineup is stuck in time. The Model S is from 2012, the Model 3 from 2017. Meanwhile, BYD, NIO, XPeng, and even legacy players like Hyundai, Volkswagen, and BMW launch fresh, feature-packed EVs every year.
BYD now sells more plug-in cars globally than Tesla — with cheaper models, faster innovation, and real interiors that don’t feel like minimalist IKEA labs.
2. No New Models in Sight
The Cybertruck arrived years late and still looks like a design dare. The “next-gen” $25 K model keeps moving further into the future. For a company once built on disruption, Tesla suddenly feels… static.
3. The Self-Driving Mirage
Elon’s “Full Self-Driving coming next year” promises have been running since 2009. Each delay feels like the Mayan end-of-the-world prophecy — always rescheduled for a later date.
If Level 5 autonomy were near, regulators, insurers, and customers would know. Instead, Tesla sells expensive “beta” features that still require human supervision.
4. Humanoid Robots and Other Distractions
Optimus, Tesla’s robot, makes for good stage demos but solving real-world bipedal movement, dexterous manipulation, and safe AI autonomy is 100 × harder than building EVs. It’s a moonshot × 10, yet it keeps stealing engineering attention.
The Numbers Don’t Lie: Valuation Has Gone Wild
Even after its price correction, Tesla trades at valuations that defy gravity:
| Metric (2025 Q3) | Tesla | Toyota | BYD |
|---|---|---|---|
| P/E (ttm) | ~70× | 10× | 26× |
| Price/Sales | ~6× | 1× | 1.4× |
| Market Cap | ≈ $760 B | $320 B | $110 B |
| Revenue Growth (YoY) | +9 % | +8 % | +38 % |
| EV Deliveries (2025 E) | ~2 M | 11 M | 3.6 M+ |
Tesla’s growth rate no longer justifies a “tech-stock” multiple. It’s a maturing automaker valued like a cloud company. Margins shrank from 30 % in 2022 to under 18 % in 2025, while BYD’s are rising.
The Competitive Reality
Once, Tesla sold aspiration. Now, competition sells innovation at half the price.
- BYD’s Seagull: $10 000 EV with decent range.
- Hyundai Ioniq 6: longer range than Model 3.
- Mercedes EQ series: tech-loaded interiors Tesla can’t match.
Tesla’s edge in batteries, charging, and software is narrowing fast. Its “moat” looks more like a puddle.
The Strategic Drift
Musk has pivoted from cars to robots, rockets, and social media crusades. None of that builds shareholder value for Tesla’s core business. Even bulls now struggle to explain how robotaxis or humanoids justify today’s price.
Meanwhile, BYD and Chinese automakers iterate faster, export globally, and dominate segments Tesla doesn’t touch — from compact city cars to plug-in hybrids.
Breaking the Rule
My Up 40 % Free Stock Strategy was supposed to make me hold free Tesla shares forever. But the word “forever” assumes the company still fits the future.
I realized I wasn’t breaking my system — I was updating it. The same rule that taught me discipline also tells me to cut exposure when fundamentals fade.
So I sold. No guilt. No stop-loss. Just a clear break.
Self-Teasing Moment
Selling Tesla felt like betraying an old friend. For a moment, I pictured Elon shaking his head on X and typing “🤡.”
But then I looked at the numbers again, smiled, and thought: I can buy a lot more future elsewhere — maybe even from BYD.
The Takeaway
Tesla was once the shining proof that innovation can rewrite entire industries. But innovation didn’t stop with Tesla — it just moved to Shenzhen, Seoul, and Wolfsburg.
Keeping “free shares forever” only works if the company keeps earning that spot. And right now, Tesla’s valuation, stagnation, and distractions make it more nostalgia than opportunity.
So I broke the rule — proudly. Sometimes, the best way to protect a strategy is to know when to bend it.
Final Thought
Selling Tesla wasn’t a loss. It was an evolution.
I took profits, protected capital, and opened space for my next chapter of free-stock adventures — maybe in companies that actually build new cars, not endless promises.
Most importantly: I WANT TO RE-BUY THOSE 30 TESLA SHARES WHEN THE GET DIRT CHEAP
BUY, SELL, KEEP 
Leave a comment